Rethinking income: MYGAs with GLWBs as a flexible alternative to SPIAs

Letter from Flourish CEO Max Lane:

Announcing the expansion and evolution of Flourish Annuities

For institutional use only.


June 12, 2025

Estimated reading time: 2 minutes

A flexible income solution that preserves client options and advisory fees.

When advisors think about income-focused annuities, the traditional choice of single premium immediate annuities (SPIAs) often come to mind. These products convert a lump sum into fixed payments and historically have been popular for offering higher payout rates than other conservative income options. However, SPIAs come with a few notable drawbacks.

Once the client makes the payment, the action is usually irrevocable, and the funds effectively vanish from both the client’s and advisor’s view. The lack of flexibility can be challenging and unsettling for clients, particularly if their needs or life circumstances change. Additionally, once those funds are locked into a SPIA, they effectively vanish from the client’s balance sheet — which can lead to reduced advisory fees. The client loses access to the funds, and both the client and advisor lose visibility, which can result in less comprehensive planning.   

Today, there’s a new approach gaining traction — one that offers lifetime income with far more flexibility, while still allowing for the opportunity to continue charging an advisory fee on those assets. Better yet, the client doesn’t have to compromise on returns to get this added adaptability.

section-annuity-replace-advisor-primer-1
section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (4)-2

Multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) paired with a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB) offer a more flexible way to generate dependable retirement income. MYGAs guarantee a fixed interest rate for a set period — think of it like a certificate of deposit (CD) with insurance company backing.††1 The addition of the GLWB rider for a fee turns the contract into a stream of income that lasts a lifetime.

Unlike many SPIAs,2 which typically pay out for a specific duration or stop upon death, MYGAs with GLWBs provide guaranteed income for life while still allowing the client to maintain access to their money should circumstances change. They can offer added protection through:

  • Steady income stream: With a GLWB, clients receive income for the duration of their life, even if the contract value is eventually depleted. Lifetime income is calculated from a separate “benefit base” designed for income payouts, which gives clients protection against outliving their savings. 
  • Spousal protection: Most MYGA contracts offer the valuable option for the income stream to continue uninterrupted for a surviving spouse, providing added security.
  • Death benefits: If there is remaining contract value when a client passes away, that amount can go to beneficiaries — something traditional SPIAs generally don’t offer. This helps alleviate a major concern some clients have with SPIAs: if they pass away shortly after transferring funds to a carrier, then the funds are effectively gone.

These features make MYGAs with GLWBs particularly appealing to clients who value income stability, added protection, and want to retain some control over their assets. That’s one reason this strategy is often referred to as “income with options.”

section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (1)-3
section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (5)-2

With MYGAs with GLWBs, there’s no financial compromise required to gain that added flexibility and protection. In fact, income rate for a MYGA with GLWB are often just as strong as what's available through a SPIA.

For example, with a leading MYGA with GLWB currently available through the Flourish Annuities marketplace, a 65-year-old client can receive a 7.30% income rate for single-life coverage as of 06/12/2025.3< Clients who don't need to draw income immediately can typically earn an even higher growth rate for each year income is deferred. To compare, we examined illustrative rates for traditional SPIAs offered by comparably rated insurance carriers, which currently offer a 7.00% payout.4

Feature MYGA w/ GLWB Traditional SPIA
Annual income
$7,300 (7.30% payout)
$7,000 (7.00% payout)
Liquidity
Full access to account value
Irrevocable; funds surrendered
Flexibility
Withdrawals can be adjusted or stopped; potential for legacy planning
No access to principal; limited or no death benefit
Advisor Fees
Ability to bill on full account value
No ongoing advisory fees; assets removed from AUM

For illustrative purposes only. This hypothetical scenario is not indicative of future performance. Results are not guaranteed.

While SPIAs may appear more straightforward, the flexibility, access to funds, and competitive lifetime income offered by MYGAs with GLWBs can make them a more dynamic solution. Rates vary depending on client age, product choice, and deferral period, but this approach offers the best of both worlds: strong income and real-world flexibility.

section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (2)-2
section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (6)-2
Of course, no solution is one-size-fits-all. While MYGAs with GLWBs offer meaningful advantages, there are other factors to consider:
  • Carrier fees apply. For example, the MYGA with GLWB that currently offers a 7.30% rate includes a 0.95% annual fee. However, that fee is currently balanced by an annual interest credit (2.75% for the first seven years, then 1% thereafter) designed to offset that cost.††
  • Access to funds may result in reduced benefits. Clients retain access to their money, but withdrawals outside the guaranteed income may reduce future benefits.
  • Surrender charges and other early withdrawal fees may apply. Like most annuities, these products may impose surrender charges if clients withdraw over specified limits too early. Surrender charges usually diminish over time.‡‡ Learn more about how these charges work in Flourish's guide to annuity surrender charges.
  • Fee billing. Management fees can't be deducted directly from the annuity. However, advisors often handle this by billing from another account.^^
section2-annuity-replace-advisor-primer-1

Most RIAs aren’t annuity specialists — and frankly, that’s a good thing. Your clients didn’t engage you to sell them insurance products; they rely on you to provide objective, holistic advice. With Flourish Annuities, you can easily offer these powerful income strategies without the operational headaches or insurance licensing. Our platform makes it easy to access fee-based annuity products with guidance and support from licensed annuity specialists. That way, you can seamlessly integrate annuities into your planning process while staying focused on what you do best: guiding your clients’ financial lives forward.

section2-annuity-replace-advisor-primer-2
section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (3)-2

In today’s volatile times, many clients can benefit from the assurances that only annuities are equipped to provide. But they also want access and control over their money. MYGAs with GLWBs offer a new way to meet those needs. With a more modern structure and flexible features, MYGAs with GLWBs open the door to a different kind of income planning conversation — one where the tradeoffs aren’t quite as stark. And, with Flourish Annuities, you have a platform built to help you seamlessly deliver this solution.

section1-annuity-replace-advisor-primer-Jun-12-2025-02-32-00-3337-AM
section2-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (1)

If you're ready to get started with bringing your clients flexible income solutions that support firm growth or learning how to replace outdated contracts through a 1035 exchange, reach out to our team of Annuities Specialists.

section2-annuity-replace-advisor-primer (2)

Related posts:

Interested in learning more about Flourish Annuities?


Flourish is an online platform through which investors can access financial services and products. Flourish’s offerings are provided by different entities and are subject to different terms, investor protections, and risks. Flourish Cash is offered by Flourish Financial LLC, a registered broker-dealer and FINRA member. Flourish Financial LLC is not a bank. Check the background of Flourish Financial LLC and its personnel on FINRA's BrokerCheck. Flourish Annuities refers generally to the annuity platform operated by Flourish Technologies LLC and to Flourish Insurance Agency LLC, and, where applicable, Flourish Financial LLC. Flourish Insurance Agency operates in its capacity as a licensed insurance producer with offices in Jersey City, New Jersey, and does business in California under the name Flourish Digital Insurance Agency, providing insurance services related to such platform. Variable annuities, defined in this context to include Registered Index-Linked Annuities (“RILAs”), are offered through Flourish Financial LLC. Annuities shown on the platform are sold through Flourish Annuities, and are issued by one or more licensed insurance companies. The Flourish entities mentioned above are affiliates. Flourish Cash and Flourish Annuities accounts are separate accounts and only assets in Flourish Cash accounts may be eligible for protection by the FDIC or SIPC. Please review the Legal section of our website, and the disclosures provided with each Flourish service or product for further information. If you were introduced or invited to Flourish by an investment advisor or other third party, please be aware that, unless otherwise disclosed to you, they are not affiliated with any Flourish entity. The role of the investment advisor or other firm that invited you to Flourish may vary between different Flourish services and products, as further described in your terms of service. © 2025 Flourish. All rights reserved.

∫ Flourish Annuities refers generally to the annuity platform operated by Flourish Technologies LLC and to Flourish Insurance Agency LLC, and, where applicable, Flourish Financial LLC. All Flourish entities are affiliates of each other. Flourish Insurance Agency operates in its capacity as a licensed insurance producer with offices in Jersey City, New Jersey, and does business in California under the name Flourish Digital Insurance Agency, providing insurance services related to such platform and the individual annuity contracts intended to be purchased by individual clients of registered investment advisors (“RIAs”). Variable annuities, defined in this context to include Registered Index-Linked Annuities (“RILAs”), are offered through Flourish Financial LLC, a registered broker-dealer and FINRA member. Flourish Financial LLC is not a bank.  

An annuity is an insurance contract. Variable annuities are considered securities. Securities are subject to investment risks, including possible loss of the principal invested. Annuities available on the platform are sold through Flourish Annuities and are issued by one or more licensed insurance companies. The issuing insurance company, not any Flourish company, is solely responsible for its own financial and contractual obligations. All benefits and guarantees of the annuity contract are subject to the claims paying ability of the issuing insurance company. This is not a proposal or a solicitation to purchase insurance and is for RIA use only. Flourish Annuities is not available to New York residents.

†† The issuing insurance company, not any Flourish company, is solely responsible for its own financial and contractual obligations. All benefits and guarantees of the annuity contract are subject to the claims paying ability of the issuing insurance company.

< Rates displayed here are subject to change at any time, including a downward change.
 
‡‡ Any withdrawals taken prior to the Contract Owner reaching the age of 59½ may also be subject to a 10% federal tax penalty, in addition to ordinary federal and state income taxes. The Contract Owner should seek legal and tax advice before making withdrawals prior to age 59½.

^^ Flourish Insurance Agency LLC and its Flourish affiliates, and issuing insurance companies do not provide tax, legal, or accounting advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, tax, legal or accounting advice. Applicants and purchasers should consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.

1 CDs and fixed annuities have different objectives, risk tolerance levels and time horizons. For example, CDs are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), while fixed annuities are not. Consumers should consult with their financial professional or agent to see which financial products may be best for their individual circumstances.

2 SPIAs and MYGAs with GLWBs are different products with different objectives, associated fees, features, and benefits. Consumers should consider all aspects of a product and their individual circumstances before choosing to invest. 

3 Income percentages are periodically set by the issuing insurance company and are subject to change.

Illustrative payout rates are based on real-time quotes for 65-year-old single-life SPIAs from leading insurance carriers. For example, New York Life’s Guaranteed Lifetime Income Annuity offers an annual payout of 6.58%, and Nationwide’s SPIA pays 7.30% annually as of 06/12/2025. These sources support the blended 7.00% comparator used in our analysis.